Welcome to Seahorse Beach House & The 50 Starfish Shack, a beautifully updated duplex offering the perfect setup for families or groups looking to enjoy a beachside getaway together while still having plenty of space and privacy. Just 150 feet from the sugar sand shores of Fort Myers Beach and located on the desirable northern end of Estero Island, this combined rental is steps away from the bustling Times Square area and the Margaritaville Resort, with its lively mix of restaurants, shops, and entertainment. From here, you'll also have easy access off the island via the Matanzas Pass Bridge, and be close to local favorites like Sanibel Island's world-famous shelling beaches, the Fort Myers River District, and even a ferry that can whisk you to Key West in under four hours.
Together, the upper and lower units offer a total of four bedrooms and three full bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to eleven guests. Guests share access to a heated swimming pool, surrounded by tropical landscaping, a privacy fence, and a paver deck with plenty of lounge seating. Whether you're sharing drinks under the covered outdoor bar, or enjoying a meal poolside, the outdoor space sets the stage for fun and relaxation.
Upstairs, Seahorse Beach House is a charming one-bedroom, one-bath home with wood flooring throughout and a private entrance via an exterior staircase. The open-plan kitchen, living, and dining area is bright and welcoming, with a peninsula bar that seats four, a dining table for four, and a living room furnished with a queen-size sleeper sofa, recliner, coffee table, and flat-screen TV. The fully equipped kitchen features a glass-top range, microwave, dishwasher, and a refrigerator with an ice maker. Just bring your groceries and you're ready to settle in. The bedroom offers a king-size bed, plenty of dresser and closet space, and a second flat-screen TV. The bathroom includes a combination tub and shower with sliding glass doors, a vanity with storage, and a wall mirror. A stacked washer and dryer is tucked neatly behind louvered doors for your convenience.
Downstairs, the 50 Starfish Shack is a spacious three-bedroom, two-bathroom unit with an open living area and direct access to the pool. The master bedroom has a king-size bed, the second bedroom has a queen, and the third bedroom features a full/single trundle bed, making it an ideal room for kids or extra guests. This third bedroom also has its own private en-suite bathroom with a walk-in shower. The second full bathroom includes a tub/shower combo. The kitchen comes fully stocked with modern appliances and essential cookware, and the adjacent dining area flows seamlessly into the living room, which is equipped with cable/satellite TV and a workspace for those needing to check in with the office. Additional features include high-speed WiFi, air conditioning, and an in-unit washer and dryer.
Each unit has its own private entrance, allowing for both connection and separation when needed. Ample off-street parking is available in front of the property, and beach access is only steps away. Whether you're lounging by the pool, exploring the vibrant local scene, or enjoying quiet mornings with coffee on the upper deck overlooking the Gulf, this property offers something for everyone.
Book your stay today and experience the best of Fort Myers Beach in a setting that feels like home, only better.
Parking accommodates a maximum of 3 vehicles. Entrance to each level is via an EXTERNAL staircase. The bikes on the ground level are NOT available for guest use.
Coastal Vacation Properties manages individual rental units and is not responsible for any construction in neighboring units, surrounding areas, or on the beach. Following hurricanes Ian, Milton, and Helene, guests should anticipate ongoing construction throughout the island. This may include construction noise, nearby building projects, increased traffic, or beach restoration efforts. We want to ensure transparency—construction is beyond our control, and we will not be offering compensation or refunds due to these conditions. By booking, guests acknowledge and accept the possibility of construction-related impacts during their stay.
