Pros-Central location in old town, very clean, quiet, beautiful and well maintained courtyard, plenty of “elbow room” for one couple, but I can see it would be tight for 3-4 people, plenty of towels
Cons-bathroom is TINY, decor is dated, bathroom and kitchen faucets need replacing, pillows need to be replaced, fixed or replaced, mattress is a little too firm for side sleepers
Overall, it met our needs but seemed a tad expensive for very outdated accommodations. Key West is generally expensive, though, so I guess you are paying for the location! Some very minor fixes and upgraded pillows/linens would make it much better.