Boendeområde
Se tillgänglighet

Recensioner av The Old Manse of Blair

5 out of 5
The Old Manse of Blair
Old Manse of Blair, Pitlochry, Scotland

Recensioner

9,2

Underbart

10 - Fantastiskt i betyg. 35 av 48 recensioner" "
8 - Bra i betyg. 9 av 48 recensioner" "
6 - Okej i betyg. 1 av 48 recensioner" "
4 - Dåligt i betyg. 1 av 48 recensioner" "
2 - Väldigt dåligt i betyg. 2 av 48 recensioner" "

9,6/10

Renlighet

9,2/10

Personal och service

9,4/10

Bekvämligheter

9,4/10

Boendets skick och faciliteter

9,0/10

Hållbarhet

Recensioner

10/10 Fantastiskt

Fredrik

Bodde här 1 natt i juli 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Semra

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Bodde här 3 nätter i november 2023

8/10 Bra

Verifierad resenär

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Very clean. Food generally very good but not quite 5 star (root veg on 1 night very very al dente and duck very salty but otherwise good). Staff very attentive yet not overbearing, which is a difficult balance to achieve. Very expensive. Especially expensive in my view is £40 per night to allow a dog to stay. Nothing provided for dog - just "allowed to stay" for that price. Other similar hotels in which we have stayed have actually made us feel welcome with the dog, rather than just being tolerated; eg they have provided titbits, or a dark towel for the dog. Even a water bowl would be appreciated.On average the other hotels have charged around £20 per night for the dog, so half the fee at the Old Manse. So overall a very pleasant stay marred only by my comments re the price which would be ok for a truly 5 star experience. This was 4-4.5 stars in my view. So nearly there but not quite. Final thing would be to please finish the car park and access to the new block. There is poor lighting up the steep bank to the car park and the covering is loose old tarmac clinker. OK for us, and that didn't detract from a nice stay, but it could be a slip hazard for anyone not totally secure with their footing.
Bodde här 2 nätter i november 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Alisha

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
I didn't want to leave!
The grounds were absolutely gorgeous - and it was a nice bonus that there was a horse, a mini pony, and a few Highland cows right on the property. We had dinner at the Orangery restaurant and it was incredible, the best food I had in Scotland.
Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Verifierad resenär

Reste med familjen
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Bodde här 2 nätter i oktober 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Jude

Reste i grupp
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Highly recommend
We had a wonderful detour due to torrential rains. This was a refreshing, relaxing stay. Andy was so hospitable, attentive and knowledgeable! We truly enjoyed our stay and highly recommend. *bed were so comfy as were the pillows!! Adding a pic of the sweet coo too!
Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Verifierad resenär

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Lovely
Lovely stay, excellent dinner. Falls of Bruar nearby well worth a look. A couple of little things that I'd mark down 1/2pt for though: £7.50 (before service charge) for a bottle of water is a lot - its not Ibiza! And an 18% service charge is a bit presumptuous - its not New York either! I'm happy to splash out on great hotels and restaurants but I don't like being nickel-and-dimed at every turn. Some feedback to Hotels.com - it could've been made clearer that breakfast was not included in our booking. It would have actually been less expensive if we booked direct.
Bodde här 1 natt i september 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Caroline

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
I really appreciated staying at n a room that opened directly into a colourful, beautifully maintained garden.
Bodde här 1 natt i augusti 2023

6/10 Okej

Verifierad resenär

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Having seen the owner respond in a passive aggressive way to any negative reviews I am a little reluctant to share my thoughts! However I rely on reviews when choosing a place to stay. The Old Manse of Blair is in a beautiful setting - the old house is stunning and the new annexes are in great condition. The staff are friendly (if a little too formal for our taste). Why the average score? For me, this property just didn’t hit the mark at the level of luxury country boutique they are striving for. It’s a perfectly comfortable place - and at a lower per night rate my review would be different - but at current rates it just doesn’t hit the mark. It’s the minor details, and as always this will be highly subjective; the details for include: 1. There are no day curtains in the annexe rooms. This means that in the morning, you can choose to lie in bed in the dark (with the curtains closed) or have them open and anyone walking past can see in…. 2. Showers would benefit from a shelf of some sort to put toiletries on (rather than the floor). 3. Fake flower decorations in dining room. Should more handmade / bespoke like the feather mirror. 4. The food is not up to the prices. Nicely presented for sure - but lacks flavour / seasoning. Breakfast in particular was poor quality. I know all of this is minor (aside from food). There are other little niggles - but we don’t have room to include! This place has huge potential. I hope owners take feedback in spirit intended).
Bodde här 1 natt i juli 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Craig

Bodde här 2 nätter i juli 2023

4/10 Dåligt

Sowndarya

Reste med sin partner
Gillade: Boendets skick och faciliteter
Gillade inte: Personal och service
There were several things about this property that made us unhappy. The marketing pictures and information on Expedia showed a king bed, a couch, and windows in the room. However, we received a twin/double bed, no windows at all, and no couch. When we asked the property, we were told “it was an upgrade since it is a historic property and we would be closer to the parking”. Even if this were the case, weren’t we supposed to be asked about this?? To add to this, there’s a train track literally on the roof and trains going by frequently when the whole room vibrates literally; the room was super hot; and the service was average at best. The only good part about this property is the area around which is pretty. But that doesn’t justify the price. Please avoid this place, and do yourself a favor.

10/10 Fantastiskt

Jonathan, Tampa

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service och boendets skick och faciliteter
Beautiful mansion and grounds just outside Blair Castle. Fantastic service and dining.
Bodde här 2 nätter i juli 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Maryanne H

Reste i grupp
Gillade: Renlighet och personal och service
So lovely. Highly recommend this boutique hotel. Lovely grounds, food and staff!
Bodde här 2 nätter i juni 2023
Svar från GM 29 juni 2023
Delighted you enjoyed your stay at The Old Manse of Blair. Thank you for taking the time to leave this great review.

10/10 Fantastiskt

Lorraine

Bodde här 1 natt i juni 2023
Svar från GM 29 juni 2023
Wow! Thank you. We love a 10/10. We appreciate you taking the time to leave us this great review.

10/10 Fantastiskt

Lara, Kensington London

Reste med familjen, Reste med husdjur
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Good location. Very friendly and helpful staff especially Marta. Food was excellent. Would definitely recommend.
Bodde här 2 nätter i april 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Gary, Glasgow

Reste med familjen
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service och boendets skick och faciliteter
Fantastic location and lovely hotel
Bodde här 1 natt i mars 2023

10/10 Fantastiskt

Mary

Reste med sin partner
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Really charming, outstanding property.
Svar från Anne 12 jan. 2023
Thank you very much for this lovely review. We are delighted you enjoyed your stay. Swing in anytime you're passing again. Warm regards

10/10 Fantastiskt

Mandeep

Reste med sin partner
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Interacting with highland cows was a great experience for me personally.
Svar från Anne 12 jan. 2023
Thank you very much for this lovely review. We are delighted you enjoyed your stay. Seumas and Seoras love meeting people and I'm glad you enjoyed meeting them too.

10/10 Fantastiskt

john

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Excellent service food extremely good
Bodde här 1 natt i november 2022
Svar från Team Old Manse of Blair 12 jan. 2023
Thank you very much for this lovely review. We are delighted you enjoyed your stay.

10/10 Fantastiskt

Marcus

Bodde här 1 natt i november 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Elspeth

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Fabulous
Everyone was absolutely delightful and very helpful. Food was beautiful and loved relaxing in front of the fire, just unfortunate pup wasn’t allowed in this area. However totally understand not everyone is dog friendly. A lovely break
Bodde här 2 nätter i oktober 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Fiona

Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Willis, SOLDOTNA

Reste i grupp, Reste med familjen, Reste med sin partner
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Beautiful hotel set in a lovely area. Highly recommended. We stayed in a lovely room just off the main house (very short walk) and enjoyed the best shower in Scotland! All in all a great place to stay if making your way to the Highlands
Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Tristan

Reste med sin partner
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Beautiful property - Lewis (the manager) was always available to assist and was very accommodating. All the staff were very friendly. Fire place in the room was a very nice amenity. Highland coos right outside the door in the pasture and very friendly. Food was quite good. A pricier experience but recommend for a special occasion.
Bodde här 2 nätter i september 2022
Svar från The Old Manse of Blair 9 okt. 2022
Dear Tristan, Thank you very much for taking the time to leave this lovely review. We greatly appreciate your feedback. Warm regards, The Old Manse of Blair

10/10 Fantastiskt

chris

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Bodde här 5 nätter i augusti 2022

8/10 Bra

Verifierad resenär

Reste i grupp
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service och boendets skick och faciliteter
Bodde här 2 nätter i juli 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Salem

Reste med sin partner
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
The owner was really friendly! She even upgraded us to the Estate Suite for our honeymoon which was great! Loved the atmosphere, cozy. The room was spacious and had a large bathroom with a walk-in shower. Friendly and welcoming vibes. Definitely looking forward to visiting again!
Bodde här 3 nätter i juli 2022

10/10 Fantastiskt

Lars

Bodde här 1 natt i juni 2022
Svar från General Manager 20 juni 2022
Thank you very much for this great review. We enjoyed meeting you both and hope the rest of your holiday was relaxing and enjoyable too. Warm regards Anne, Pete & Team

8/10 Bra

Verifierad resenär

Gillade: Renlighet, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Great stay
Overall a lovely stay and beautiful setting. The rooms were very clean and amenities great. Good selection of continental and cooked breakfast. The evening meal was really delicious. Some lack of training of staff noted though, could be more courteous.
Bodde här 2 nätter i juni 2022
Svar från General Manager 20 juni 2022
Thank you very much for taking the time to review your stay. I am glad you enjoyed your stay and experience in the restaurant.

10/10 Fantastiskt

Berkem

Bodde här 1 natt i maj 2022
Svar från General Manager 23 maj 2022
Thank you for taking the time to leave us your feedback. Warm regards, Alan and Team

10/10 Fantastiskt

May

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Lovely boutique hotel, intimate dining room with nice food. Very attentive, friendly management and staff
Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2021

10/10 Fantastiskt

Verifierad resenär

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Room was extremely clean and comfortable. Friendly staff
Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2021

10/10 Fantastiskt

Neil

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
House of Bruar Trip
Perfect get away for my wife and me where we fancied a trip into the highlands, and a look around House of Bruar and Pitlochry. Found this hotel with its own amazing restaurant in such a great setting. House of Bruar is only about a mile away if that.
Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2021

10/10 Fantastiskt

Amanda

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
A great place to stay.
Excellent place to stay. The welcome and organisation was very good and the Hotel is delightful.
An amazing building with beautiful rooms and setting.
Bodde här 1 natt i augusti 2021

2/10 Väldigt dåligt

Verifierad resenär

Reste med familjen
Gillade inte: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Worst Experience !! Not ideal for a family!!
Not ideal for a family!! We got confirmation from Hotel that the Ensuite room is suitable for a couple with infants. However, at the time of arriving in the evening, hotel staff declined to give keys for the room booked for and asked for an additional cost (almost the same amount that we paid already). They were forced to take that room which was not listed at any other website except their own. Hotel taking advantage of customer situations, timing and remote location. We ended up with an infant almost three hours in the car at the parking area without accessing basic utilities of drinking water, toilet, etc. Hotel can show the room which they want to sell but refused to show the room which we have booked for due to safety concerns. Be careful before visiting this place. It's not ideal for family at all and not trustworthy even.
Bodde här 1 natt i juni 2021
Svar från Reservations 16 juli 2021
Dear Mr Shah, you booked and reserved a room for two people before arriving with extended family. You were told the room was only suitable for two people. The health and safety of our guests is paramount, this is why we have policies and procedures in place. We tried to assist you and indeed spent time to find alternative solutions for you. We welcome many families to our hotel who have a wonderful experience here in the National Park. I would advise you to reserve a room suitable for the number of people travelling in your party and take the guidance of the reservation team when they tell you the capacity of the room. Your children were playing in the grounds with the chickens and watching the Highland Cows when you were rearranging your travel, to suggest otherwise is simply untrue.

8/10 Bra

Andrew

Gillade: Renlighet, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Good stay, with slight disappointment
The property was of a high standard. We had been booked in for dinner but unfortunately we were informed the chef was unwell just prior to check in. This meant we had to find our own last minute dinner solution locally. This was disappointing and it would have been appreciated if more had been done to alleviate this inconvenience. This aside the stay was enjoyable.
Bodde här 1 natt i juni 2021

8/10 Bra

Elspeth

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2020
Svar från Tracey Smith, General Manager 30 okt. 2020
Many thanks for taking the time to provide a review. We look forward to welcoming you back again soon. Warmest regards Tracey

10/10 Fantastiskt

colin

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Fantastic
Fantastic and beautiful location.
Bodde här 1 natt i oktober 2020

2/10 Väldigt dåligt

Laurence

Gillade: Renlighet och personal och service
Gillade inte: Rummets bekvämlighet
Disappointing
We booked this assuming it was a luxury hotel based on the rating and cost. The food offering was very good and the waiting staff were friendly and professional. However, our room was disappointingly small and because it was over the open fire in the lounge much too hot. The only means of cooling it down was opening the windows. Despite a long journey we couldn't get to sleep and were reduced to removing the 13.5 Tog duvet from its cover to try and get to sleep. We were very tired in the morning and when we raised the problem with the owner she accused us of having a COVID fever and told us to leave immediately. We didn't have any infection and were kindly taken in by an excellent hotel in Pitlochry which was half the price and much nicer and had much more effective COVID security We are still awaiting repayment of the 4 nights we didn't spend at the Old Manse. We would never go there again and would recommend any other travellers considering it to think very carefully before booking. There are much better and cheaper hotels in the vicinity.
Bodde här 5 nätter i oktober 2020
Svar från Tracey Smith, General Manager 10 okt. 2020
Thank you for your review, your assumption that The Old Manse of Blair is a luxury hotel is indeed correct. I am pleased your enjoyed The Orangery Restaurant and our team were warm and friendly and professional during your stay. I was disappointed to read your comments with regards to your room which is described accurately as a large room on the first floor, with views over the paddocks, king size bed, large bathroom with separate bath and shower and double vanity with floor space of 313Sq ft this room by industry standard is certainly not small! With regards to the room being too hot there is a thermostat on the bedroom wall to allow you to control the temperature. The fire in the lounge may indeed have added a degree or two of heat, however with the current 10pm government guideline the fire is dying out by 10pm and fully out at 10.30pm therefore would not have caused additional heat 'throughout the night'. With all of this in mind and a global pandemic which seems to be worsening our Owner was quite justifiably concerned and acted within our Covid policy and risk assessments to ask you both to leave the premises for the protection of our staff and other guests. To clarify you have paid hotels.com and they then pay The Old Manse of Blair - we have not received the payment for your stay as yet and I have advised hotels.com that we will only charge for the one night that you stayed. I am glad you managed to find a cheaper hotel more suited to your needs albeit surprised you were admitted anywhere displaying Covid-19 symptoms. We are incredibly strict on our procedures and take our duty of care incredibly seriously. Best Regards Tracey Smith

8/10 Bra

Ashley

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
great stay
It was a lovely room the smart tv was great the free standing bath was amazing
Bodde här 1 natt i augusti 2020
Svar från Tracey Smith 24 sep. 2020
Delighted you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you back again soon. Warmest regards Tracey

8/10 Bra

Verifierad resenär

Gillade: Personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Bodde här 2 nätter i augusti 2020
Svar från Tracey Smith, General Manager 10 okt. 2020
Dear Anonymous Many thanks for your review, we hope to welcome you back to The Old Manse of Blair in the future. Warmest regards Tracey

10/10 Fantastiskt

Verifierad resenär

Reste med sin partner
Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, bekvämligheter och boendets skick och faciliteter
Food is excellent as is the hospitality, you are made to feel very welcome
Bodde här 2 nätter i mars 2020

10/10 Fantastiskt

Andrew

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Perfect place to getaway to!
Amazing location - if you want a place away from the bustle this is perfect! You can lose yourself in the country or explore the many villages and towns in stone throw of the hotel. Food on site was great too, the breakfast was perfect and highly recommended too :). Will definitely be back, we stayed in the Paddock room which was super comfortable and had an amazing free standing bath, perfect to unwind in!
Bodde här 1 natt i februari 2020
Svar från Tracey 22 feb. 2020
Dear Andrew Many thanks for your fantastic comments! It was my pleasure to welcome you and look forward to seeing you again soon. Warmest regards Tracey

8/10 Bra

Verifierad resenär

Gillade: Renlighet
Bodde här 2 nätter i oktober 2019

10/10 Fantastiskt

Alex

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Wonderful host, luxurious hotel.
Anne was the most wonderful host. She gave us some fabulous tips for things to do, and really, truly looked after us both. The hotel is a wonderful slice of luxury and the food was sensational! We left with some interior design inspiration, an even greater love of Scotland and a wonderful contact in Anne. We will definitely be back, hopefully when the sun comes out!
Bodde här 2 nätter i augusti 2019
Svar från Owner 25 aug. 2019
Thank you both for this wonderful feedback. We look forward to your return and are delighted you enjoyed your time with us at The Old Manse of Blair. We love taking care of people and making your time with us relaxing and enjoyable. We are fortunate to have a wonderful head chef who must take all the credit for the sensational food! Warmest regards, Anne

10/10 Fantastiskt

Sandra

Gillade: Renlighet, personal och service, boendets skick och faciliteter och rummets bekvämlighet
Accueil très chaleureux dans une magnifique demeure décorée avec goût. Dîner absolument délicieux et soigné. Petit-déjeuner magnifique. Nous retournerons sans hésiter et recommandons cet établissement. Chambre et lits très confortables.
Bodde här 1 natt i augusti 2019