Great hotel off the beaten path. As a couple, we found it a wonderful place to explore Key West, without actually being in Key West. The facilities are beautiful, very well maintained, clean and comfortable. Staff was friendly, attentive and efficient.
Must keep in mind, though, that it is rather far from Old Town: a 20-minute car ride, or $25 rideshare. However, if you (as we did) want to avoid the noise and crowds of Key West (or control when and how not to avoid them), then this is a great place to stay.