The summary: Rent this house. Great location, well stocked, clean, beautiful pool/hot tub, overall near perfect experience.
The details: Rented for two weeks for family of four - two kids 11, 13. We were looking for a relaxing somewhat quiet area that still had things to do and AMI was perfect. You don't really need to leave the house because the pool and hot tub are fantastic. Both are saltwater which was barely noticeable but great as no chlorine smell. The water system for the hot tub kept a constantly fresh supply of water flowing into the tub which made it look and feel very clean. The attached shed is filled with slightly worn but still appreciated pool toys, beach necessities like umbrellas, chairs and even a wagon to haul them all to the beach. Very thoughtful.
The house itself is relatively basic but clean and well laid out. Plenty of towels (including beach towels) included and the kitchen was very well stocked. The walls are thin so you may hear a bit from the neighbors but it was never a major problem at all. TV's all equipped with Rokus.
I don't think there's really a bad location on AMI, but this house is very well situated in a lovely neighborhood a short 2-3 block walk to the beach and a block or two from several excellent restaurants and stores - do not miss the Ugly Grouper, Feast and the little Italian market/carryout restaurant down the street. The lack of chain restaurants on this island is remarkable and creates a really pleasant vibe in addition to the some of the best food we've had on a vacation in a long time.
Owners were responsive and very pleasant - it's clear they are looking to deliver an above-average rental experience and they have succeeded. Thank you we will be back!